We see it time and time again, right in our chairs at First & Mane. The client comes in, describes what they are looking for, and confesses that they can never quite capture the look on their own at home. The trouble, more often than not, isn’t their skill or the quality of the cut. It simply has to do with the fact that they are working with the wrong product. The hair care section of the drugstore can be overwhelming, and it is common practice to simply grab what you see and go.
To help you upgrade your daily routine, we are going to break down two of the biggest players in the male grooming industry: pomade vs hair gel. Knowing how each works and their chemistry will give your hair the same look whether it’s been cut or not.
Understanding the Classic Pomade
Pomade is the traditional gentlemen’s grooming product. If you can picture the slicked back hairstyles of the 1950s, or the pompadours and quiffs we cut today, you can picture pomade. Traditionally, these products were oil-based, which means that they were very hard to wash out of the hair.
In today’s market, we’d suggest you look for water-based pomades. They provide you with the same pliable hold without the grease, and they come out easily at the end of the day. Flexibility is the main attribute you want to remember in this regard. Pomade does not crunch or harden. It allows you to comb your hair at 2 PM and restyle it with the ease you had at 8 AM. It is made to work with your hair, not against it.
The High Hold of Hair Gel
Hair gel is probably the first styling product you used in high school. It is renowned for its maximum hold and extreme high shine. In contrast to pomade, hair gel uses alcohol and hold polymers to hold hair in place. Once it dries, it will stay in the position you placed it in until you wash it off.
This formulation gives it a stiff hold, which is nearly wind-resistant. Although it went out of fashion for a short period when natural hairstyles became the fashion, gels work well for a particular kind of styled hair where the enemy is movement. It gives a wet look that will last all day, although it is not touch-friendly.
Comparison of the Finish and Feel
The largest difference between gel and pomade is in finish and feel. The gel dries into a shell around the hair shaft that has an extreme hold but no give. If you try to touch your hair after you have dried it with gel, you’ll see that your hold is broken and often comes out as white flakes on your shoulders. It is a set it and forget it type of product.
The pomade can still be worked with throughout the day. Also, it won’t dry out the hair. As for its components, gels contain high amounts of alcohol, which dries out the scalp when used on a daily basis without using an appropriate conditioner. The pomade is less harsh on the scalp area compared to gels when it comes to shine finish – matte to high shine.
Picking the Right Choice for Your Hair Type
Choosing the winner is completely dependent on your hair type and the look you’re trying to create. For instance, if you have really thick and frizzy hair, and you’re looking for something to help you defy gravity and create spikes or a sharply defined side part, then you’re looking for the help of the former in the hair gel vs pomade debate.
But for those with thinner hair or those who like a natural flow, we highly recommend the use of the former between pomade or gel. This not only gives your hair volume and texture, it also doesn’t weigh your hair down and doesn’t show your scalp by matting your hair together in chunks.
If you like to run your fingers through your hair, don’t use gel. If you like your hairstyle to look exactly the same when you get home as it did when you left the house, gel may be the solution.
The Hunt for the Perfect Finish
A good start to upgrading your grooming routine involves knowing what goes on your head. If you’re a man who requires the sturdy hold of a gel or the refined and flexible hold of a pomade, the key to your confidence boost begins with the right tool.
But if you’re still not sure which tub you’d rather grab, gel or pomade, just come on down to our shop for your next haircut. We’d be happy to evaluate your hair type and walk you through exactly how you can apply our product for that freshly barbered look every morning. For expert advice and a great cut, experience our barbershop services firsthand at First & Mane!
Dru is the owner and master barber at FIRST & MANE in Scottsdale. With years of expertise, he’s known for precision cuts and modern grooming techniques that keep clients looking their best.